Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops ›› 2020, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (11): 2259-2266.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-2561.2020.11.016
• Plant Protection & Bio-safety • Previous Articles Next Articles
QUAN Dawan1,4,LI Dong2,ZHANG Jinlian3,4,*(),SONG Juan4,HU Liu2,CHENG Tong3,HUANG Jinghua1,*(
),CHEN Tingsu4
Received:
2019-09-18
Revised:
2019-11-06
Online:
2020-11-25
Published:
2020-12-23
Contact:
ZHANG Jinlian,HUANG Jinghua
CLC Number:
QUAN Dawan,LI Dong,ZHANG Jinlian,SONG Juan,HU Liu,CHENG Tong,HUANG Jinghua,CHEN Tingsu. Effects of Inhibition Citrus Huanglongbing on Catharanthus roseus with Different Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi Species[J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(11): 2259-2266.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: http://www.rdzwxb.com/EN/10.3969/j.issn.1000-2561.2020.11.016
序号No. | 学名 Scientific name | 菌株编号 Strain number | 每盆用量 Eachdosage of basin/g | 菌株来源 Source of strain |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Acaulospora bireticulata | JX70 | 20 | 柑橘 |
2 | Acaulospora bireticulata | JX80 | 20 | 柑橘 |
3 | Glomeromycota sp1 | JX126 | 20 | 柑橘 |
4 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | JX145 | 20 | 柑橘 |
5 | Rhizophagus manihotis | JX165 | 20 | 柑橘 |
6 | Acaulospora scrobiculata | GZ1 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
7 | Rhizophagus intraradices | GZ5 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
8 | Paraglomus sp. | GZ10 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
9 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | LC-C58 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
10 | Funneliformis mosseae | E16-1-32 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
11 | Rhizophagus irregularis | E26-47 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
12 | Glomeromycota sp2 | BNMJ | 20 | 香蕉 |
13 | Glomeromycota sp3 | HTJ2-60 | 20 | 香蕉 |
14 | Glomeromycota sp4 | LJCK | 20 | 香蕉 |
15 | Glomeromycota sp5 | LSJ | 20 | 生姜 |
16 | Glomeromycota sp6 | NGJ | 20 | 生姜 |
17 | Glomeromycota sp7 | PWJ | 20 | 生姜 |
Tab. 1 Different species of AM fungi
序号No. | 学名 Scientific name | 菌株编号 Strain number | 每盆用量 Eachdosage of basin/g | 菌株来源 Source of strain |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Acaulospora bireticulata | JX70 | 20 | 柑橘 |
2 | Acaulospora bireticulata | JX80 | 20 | 柑橘 |
3 | Glomeromycota sp1 | JX126 | 20 | 柑橘 |
4 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | JX145 | 20 | 柑橘 |
5 | Rhizophagus manihotis | JX165 | 20 | 柑橘 |
6 | Acaulospora scrobiculata | GZ1 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
7 | Rhizophagus intraradices | GZ5 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
8 | Paraglomus sp. | GZ10 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
9 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | LC-C58 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
10 | Funneliformis mosseae | E16-1-32 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
11 | Rhizophagus irregularis | E26-47 | 20 | 甘蔗 |
12 | Glomeromycota sp2 | BNMJ | 20 | 香蕉 |
13 | Glomeromycota sp3 | HTJ2-60 | 20 | 香蕉 |
14 | Glomeromycota sp4 | LJCK | 20 | 香蕉 |
15 | Glomeromycota sp5 | LSJ | 20 | 生姜 |
16 | Glomeromycota sp6 | NGJ | 20 | 生姜 |
17 | Glomeromycota sp7 | PWJ | 20 | 生姜 |
等级分类 Levels | 等级症状特点 Characteristics of symptoms |
---|---|
0级 | 未显症的植株。 |
Ⅰ级 | 植株开始显症,显症叶片小于10%,仅在嫁接点附近叶片呈现黄化症状(在叶片上呈现黄色斑点)。其他枝条无症状。 |
Ⅱ级 | 植株10%~40%的叶片呈现黄化病症。其他枝条未显症,但伴随有叶片凋落或顶芽生长异常的现象。 |
Ⅲ级 | 植株40%~70%叶片呈现HLB病症,在双枝条或多枝条植株中嫁接枝条全部显症。另外的枝条也有30%~50%左右的叶片呈现黄化病症,有些植株伴随有叶片凋落,或不再长出新芽或新芽生长缓慢,或不能成花或花变小变畸形。 |
Ⅳ级 | 植株70%~90%以上的叶片呈现黄化病症,在双枝条或多枝条植株中嫁接病叶的枝条全部叶片显症。另外的枝条有50%~80%的叶片呈现病症,有些植株或有叶片凋落,或顶芽畸形,或不能成花,或生长缓慢缺乏生气,或无新生芽叶,或有新生芽叶但生长缓慢,或以上几种症状并发。 |
Ⅴ级 | 植株全株叶片(100%)呈现黄化病症,有些植株大量落叶、不能成花、生长缓慢。 |
Ⅵ级 | 植株萎蔫死亡。 |
Tab. 2 Criteria for classification of susceptibility to HLB of C. roseus
等级分类 Levels | 等级症状特点 Characteristics of symptoms |
---|---|
0级 | 未显症的植株。 |
Ⅰ级 | 植株开始显症,显症叶片小于10%,仅在嫁接点附近叶片呈现黄化症状(在叶片上呈现黄色斑点)。其他枝条无症状。 |
Ⅱ级 | 植株10%~40%的叶片呈现黄化病症。其他枝条未显症,但伴随有叶片凋落或顶芽生长异常的现象。 |
Ⅲ级 | 植株40%~70%叶片呈现HLB病症,在双枝条或多枝条植株中嫁接枝条全部显症。另外的枝条也有30%~50%左右的叶片呈现黄化病症,有些植株伴随有叶片凋落,或不再长出新芽或新芽生长缓慢,或不能成花或花变小变畸形。 |
Ⅳ级 | 植株70%~90%以上的叶片呈现黄化病症,在双枝条或多枝条植株中嫁接病叶的枝条全部叶片显症。另外的枝条有50%~80%的叶片呈现病症,有些植株或有叶片凋落,或顶芽畸形,或不能成花,或生长缓慢缺乏生气,或无新生芽叶,或有新生芽叶但生长缓慢,或以上几种症状并发。 |
Ⅴ级 | 植株全株叶片(100%)呈现黄化病症,有些植株大量落叶、不能成花、生长缓慢。 |
Ⅵ级 | 植株萎蔫死亡。 |
菌株编号 Strain number | 根外菌丝 Hyphae on root/% | 根内菌丝 Internal hyphae/% | 泡囊 Vesicles/% | 菌根侵染率 AM fungi infection rate/% |
---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
JX70 | 5.70±9.75bcde | 15.60±24.98abc | 1.75±6.74ab | 19.35±29.30abc |
JX80 | 3.50±7.27cde | 15.50±23.45abcd | 0.00±0.00bc | 18.75±28.00abcd |
JX126 | 11.90±11.18a | 23.25±24.36ab | 0.50±1.54bc | 32.35±31.50a |
JX145 | 1.90±5.44de | 5.00±15.64cd | 0.25±1.12bc | 7.60±22.62cd |
JX165 | 1.25±2.71e | 3.40±6.02cd | 0.35±0.75bc | 4.55±8.42cd |
GZ1 | 8.75±10.96ab | 28.50±32.67a | 2.35±3.22a | 31.85±36.00ab |
GZ5 | 1.95±3.12de | 12.30±23.45abcd | 0.40±1.27bc | 13.45±24.32bcd |
GZ10 | 7.40±10.04abcd | 20.00±26.94abc | 0.80±2.12bc | 23.90±30.72abc |
LC-C58 | 1.00±1.33e | 2.00±2.62d | 0.00±0.00bc | 3.00±3.89d |
E16-1-32 | 9.75±10.82ab | 26.00±28.17a | 0.90±2.13bc | 31.75±33.02ab |
E26-47 | 1.79±2.09de | 5.36±6.76cd | 0.36±0.76bc | 7.15±8.75cd |
BNMJ | 4.75±5.50bcde | 10.25±9.51bcd | 0.00±0.00bc | 13.70±11.68abcd |
HTJ2-60 | 1.05±1.42e | 5.00±7.45cd | 0.40±0.84bc | 6.05±8.62cd |
LJCK | 2.13±2.52cde | 7.84±8.86bcd | 1.00±1.76abc | 9.25±10.61cd |
LSJ | 11.25±9.80a | 19.44±16.26abc | 0.00±0.00bc | 29.75±25.45ab |
NGJ | 7.90±8.86abc | 5.00±6.24cd | 0.50±1.08bc | 12.90±14.75bcd |
PWJ | 4.30±7.94bcde | 18.65±32.73abc | 0.00±0.00bc | 20.25±34.19abc |
Tab. 3 Infection in the roots of C. roseus with different AM fungi
菌株编号 Strain number | 根外菌丝 Hyphae on root/% | 根内菌丝 Internal hyphae/% | 泡囊 Vesicles/% | 菌根侵染率 AM fungi infection rate/% |
---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
JX70 | 5.70±9.75bcde | 15.60±24.98abc | 1.75±6.74ab | 19.35±29.30abc |
JX80 | 3.50±7.27cde | 15.50±23.45abcd | 0.00±0.00bc | 18.75±28.00abcd |
JX126 | 11.90±11.18a | 23.25±24.36ab | 0.50±1.54bc | 32.35±31.50a |
JX145 | 1.90±5.44de | 5.00±15.64cd | 0.25±1.12bc | 7.60±22.62cd |
JX165 | 1.25±2.71e | 3.40±6.02cd | 0.35±0.75bc | 4.55±8.42cd |
GZ1 | 8.75±10.96ab | 28.50±32.67a | 2.35±3.22a | 31.85±36.00ab |
GZ5 | 1.95±3.12de | 12.30±23.45abcd | 0.40±1.27bc | 13.45±24.32bcd |
GZ10 | 7.40±10.04abcd | 20.00±26.94abc | 0.80±2.12bc | 23.90±30.72abc |
LC-C58 | 1.00±1.33e | 2.00±2.62d | 0.00±0.00bc | 3.00±3.89d |
E16-1-32 | 9.75±10.82ab | 26.00±28.17a | 0.90±2.13bc | 31.75±33.02ab |
E26-47 | 1.79±2.09de | 5.36±6.76cd | 0.36±0.76bc | 7.15±8.75cd |
BNMJ | 4.75±5.50bcde | 10.25±9.51bcd | 0.00±0.00bc | 13.70±11.68abcd |
HTJ2-60 | 1.05±1.42e | 5.00±7.45cd | 0.40±0.84bc | 6.05±8.62cd |
LJCK | 2.13±2.52cde | 7.84±8.86bcd | 1.00±1.76abc | 9.25±10.61cd |
LSJ | 11.25±9.80a | 19.44±16.26abc | 0.00±0.00bc | 29.75±25.45ab |
NGJ | 7.90±8.86abc | 5.00±6.24cd | 0.50±1.08bc | 12.90±14.75bcd |
PWJ | 4.30±7.94bcde | 18.65±32.73abc | 0.00±0.00bc | 20.25±34.19abc |
Fig. 1 Infection of AM fungi in C. roseus roots A: Micrograph of hyphae on root; B: Micrograph of hyphae in root; C: Micrograph of vesicles; D: Micrograph of arbuscule.
菌株编号 Strain number | 茎径Stem diameter/mm | 株高Plant height/cm | 叶片数Leaf number | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
25 d | 50 d | 75 d | 25 d | 50 d | 75 d | 25 d | 50 d | 75 d | |
CK | 1.38±0.11i | 1.94±0.25ef | 2.90±0.33bcdef | 2.70±0.55cde | 5.46±0.71cdefg | 10.16±1.47bcdef | 4.00±0.00fh | 7.20±1.03fg | 11.60±1.26bcde |
JX70 | 1.82±0.39cdefg | 2.30±0.36bcd | 3.01±0.37abcd | 3.01±0.84abc | 6.07±1.85cdef | 10.87±2.91abcde | 5.57±1.40abc | 9.14±1.70abc | 12.64±1.22ab |
JX80 | 1.92±0.28bcd | 1.93±0.33ef | 2.44±0.29gh | 2.73±0.83cde | 4.75±1.18g | 8.05±1.90g | 4.80±1.01defg | 7.07±1.67g | 9.53±1.55g |
JX126 | 2.20±0.29a | 2.37±0.27bc | 3.07±0.33abc | 3.39±0.60ab | 7.47±1.10a | 11.77±1.90ab | 5.87±0.52a | 9.43±1.83ab | 12.13±1.30abcde |
JX145 | 1.79±0.33cdefg | 2.17±0.39cde | 2.67±0.46efgh | 3.40±0.91ab | 6.44±1.87abcd | 9.56±3.63defg | 4.67±0.98defgh | 8.57±1.65bcde | 11.27±1.71def |
JX165 | 1.49±0.20hi | 1.92±0.29ef | 2.62±0.38fgh | 2.87±0.69bcd | 5.71±1.15cdefg | 9.29±1.58efg | 4.93±1.03bcde | 7.67±1.59efg | 11.07±1.53ef |
GZ1 | 1.91±0.33bcde | 2.38±0.25bc | 2.97±0.31abcde | 3.05±1.14abc | 6.51±2.37abc | 11.52±3.38abc | 4.80±1.03cdef | 9.20±1.40abc | 12.40±1.58abcd |
GZ5 | 1.73±0.39defgh | 2.39±0.32abc | 2.97±0.32abcde | 2.82±0.82cde | 6.18±1.66bcde | 10.39±2.58bcde | 5.00±1.05bcde | 9.00±1.70abcd | 13.10±2.51a |
GZ10 | 1.96±0.47abcd | 2.62±0.31a | 3.25±0.43a | 3.49±0.78a | 7.32±1.84ab | 12.51±2.65a | 5.60±0.83abc | 10.13±2.10a | 12.60±1.92abc |
LC-C58 | 1.73±0.26defgh | 2.09±0.35def | 2.81±0.28cdef | 2.85±0.67bcde | 5.79±0.86cdefg | 9.61±1.16cdefg | 4.53±1.19defgh | 7.47±1.19efg | 11.47±1.19cde |
E16-1-32 | 1.92±0.35bcde | 2.20±0.24cd | 3.05±0.29abcd | 2.59±0.57cde | 5.68±1.26cdefg | 9.61±1.81defg | 5.20±1.01abcd | 8.13±1.19cdefg | 11.20±1.26def |
E26-47 | 1.98±0.46abc | 1.90±0.27f | 2.39±0.37h | 2.76±0.51cde | 5.09±1.36efg | 8.44±2.09fg | 4.82±0.98cde | 7.45±1.81efg | 10.18±1.66fg |
BNMJ | 1.47±0.41i | 2.26±0.39bcd | 3.05±0.41abcd | 2.52±0.51cde | 6.17±1.88cde | 11.33±3.55abcd | 5.00±1.05bcde | 9.10±1.37abcd | 12.20±1.23abcde |
HTJ2-60 | 1.55±0.23ghi | 2.26±0.33bcd | 2.87±0.38bcdef | 2.34±0.72de | 5.26±1.39defg | 10.04±2.46bcdef | 5.00±1.04bcde | 8.43±1.60bcdef | 11.71±1.90bcde |
LJCK | 2.09±0.36ab | 2.28±0.41bcd | 3.06±0.54abc | 3.01±0.68abc | 6.26±1.40abcde | 10.61±2.62abcde | 5.83±0.58a | 8.83±1.59bcd | 12.08±1.93abcde |
LSJ | 1.59±0.29fghi | 1.96±0.18ef | 2.93±0.38bcde | 2.31±0.55e | 4.82±1.10fg | 9.08±2.07efg | 4.22±0.67efgh | 7.78±1.20defg | 11.56±0.88bcde |
NGJ | 1.83±0.36cdef | 2.46±0.42ab | 3.12±0.50ab | 2.77±0.61cde | 5.76±1.81cdefg | 10.25±2.71bcde | 5.64±1.34ab | 9.29±1.98abc | 12.29±1.73abcde |
PWJ | 1.64±0.17efghi | 2.31±0.17bcd | 2.75±0.39defg | 3.08±0.85abc | 6.30±1.22abcd | 10.57±1.77bcde | 5.10±0.99abcd | 8.80±1.03bcde | 12.30±1.34abcde |
Tab. 4 C. roseus stem diameter, plant height and leaf number inoculated with different AM fungi
菌株编号 Strain number | 茎径Stem diameter/mm | 株高Plant height/cm | 叶片数Leaf number | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
25 d | 50 d | 75 d | 25 d | 50 d | 75 d | 25 d | 50 d | 75 d | |
CK | 1.38±0.11i | 1.94±0.25ef | 2.90±0.33bcdef | 2.70±0.55cde | 5.46±0.71cdefg | 10.16±1.47bcdef | 4.00±0.00fh | 7.20±1.03fg | 11.60±1.26bcde |
JX70 | 1.82±0.39cdefg | 2.30±0.36bcd | 3.01±0.37abcd | 3.01±0.84abc | 6.07±1.85cdef | 10.87±2.91abcde | 5.57±1.40abc | 9.14±1.70abc | 12.64±1.22ab |
JX80 | 1.92±0.28bcd | 1.93±0.33ef | 2.44±0.29gh | 2.73±0.83cde | 4.75±1.18g | 8.05±1.90g | 4.80±1.01defg | 7.07±1.67g | 9.53±1.55g |
JX126 | 2.20±0.29a | 2.37±0.27bc | 3.07±0.33abc | 3.39±0.60ab | 7.47±1.10a | 11.77±1.90ab | 5.87±0.52a | 9.43±1.83ab | 12.13±1.30abcde |
JX145 | 1.79±0.33cdefg | 2.17±0.39cde | 2.67±0.46efgh | 3.40±0.91ab | 6.44±1.87abcd | 9.56±3.63defg | 4.67±0.98defgh | 8.57±1.65bcde | 11.27±1.71def |
JX165 | 1.49±0.20hi | 1.92±0.29ef | 2.62±0.38fgh | 2.87±0.69bcd | 5.71±1.15cdefg | 9.29±1.58efg | 4.93±1.03bcde | 7.67±1.59efg | 11.07±1.53ef |
GZ1 | 1.91±0.33bcde | 2.38±0.25bc | 2.97±0.31abcde | 3.05±1.14abc | 6.51±2.37abc | 11.52±3.38abc | 4.80±1.03cdef | 9.20±1.40abc | 12.40±1.58abcd |
GZ5 | 1.73±0.39defgh | 2.39±0.32abc | 2.97±0.32abcde | 2.82±0.82cde | 6.18±1.66bcde | 10.39±2.58bcde | 5.00±1.05bcde | 9.00±1.70abcd | 13.10±2.51a |
GZ10 | 1.96±0.47abcd | 2.62±0.31a | 3.25±0.43a | 3.49±0.78a | 7.32±1.84ab | 12.51±2.65a | 5.60±0.83abc | 10.13±2.10a | 12.60±1.92abc |
LC-C58 | 1.73±0.26defgh | 2.09±0.35def | 2.81±0.28cdef | 2.85±0.67bcde | 5.79±0.86cdefg | 9.61±1.16cdefg | 4.53±1.19defgh | 7.47±1.19efg | 11.47±1.19cde |
E16-1-32 | 1.92±0.35bcde | 2.20±0.24cd | 3.05±0.29abcd | 2.59±0.57cde | 5.68±1.26cdefg | 9.61±1.81defg | 5.20±1.01abcd | 8.13±1.19cdefg | 11.20±1.26def |
E26-47 | 1.98±0.46abc | 1.90±0.27f | 2.39±0.37h | 2.76±0.51cde | 5.09±1.36efg | 8.44±2.09fg | 4.82±0.98cde | 7.45±1.81efg | 10.18±1.66fg |
BNMJ | 1.47±0.41i | 2.26±0.39bcd | 3.05±0.41abcd | 2.52±0.51cde | 6.17±1.88cde | 11.33±3.55abcd | 5.00±1.05bcde | 9.10±1.37abcd | 12.20±1.23abcde |
HTJ2-60 | 1.55±0.23ghi | 2.26±0.33bcd | 2.87±0.38bcdef | 2.34±0.72de | 5.26±1.39defg | 10.04±2.46bcdef | 5.00±1.04bcde | 8.43±1.60bcdef | 11.71±1.90bcde |
LJCK | 2.09±0.36ab | 2.28±0.41bcd | 3.06±0.54abc | 3.01±0.68abc | 6.26±1.40abcde | 10.61±2.62abcde | 5.83±0.58a | 8.83±1.59bcd | 12.08±1.93abcde |
LSJ | 1.59±0.29fghi | 1.96±0.18ef | 2.93±0.38bcde | 2.31±0.55e | 4.82±1.10fg | 9.08±2.07efg | 4.22±0.67efgh | 7.78±1.20defg | 11.56±0.88bcde |
NGJ | 1.83±0.36cdef | 2.46±0.42ab | 3.12±0.50ab | 2.77±0.61cde | 5.76±1.81cdefg | 10.25±2.71bcde | 5.64±1.34ab | 9.29±1.98abc | 12.29±1.73abcde |
PWJ | 1.64±0.17efghi | 2.31±0.17bcd | 2.75±0.39defg | 3.08±0.85abc | 6.30±1.22abcd | 10.57±1.77bcde | 5.10±0.99abcd | 8.80±1.03bcde | 12.30±1.34abcde |
菌株编号 Strain number | 鲜重 Fresh biomass/g | 干重 Dry weight/g | 菌株编号 Strain number | 鲜重 Fresh biomass/g | 干重 Dry weight/g |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 51.56±7.70def | 10.28±0.76bcd | LC-C58 | 52.48±5.66cdef | 9.00±1.75def |
JX70 | 63.68±4.90a | 13.08±0.79a | E16-1-32 | 54.03±3.59cde | 9.60±1.28bcdef |
JX80 | 44.25±1.37g | 8.36±0.63ef | E26-47 | 53.70±2.58cdef | 10.26±0.80bcd |
JX126 | 46.63±5.83fg | 8.17±1.51f | BNMJ | 51.92±1.39def | 11.01±0.96b |
JX145 | 56.55±3.25abcd | 10.09±0.69bcde | HTJ2-60 | 54.80±5.94bcd | 10.19±0.67bcd |
JX165 | 47.21±0.92efg | 8.37±0.60ef | LJCK | 55.60±3.86bcd | 10.76±1.01bc |
GZ1 | 50.99±8.32def | 9.15±1.87cdef | LSJ | 59.85±2.46abc | 11.02±0.68b |
GZ5 | 55.39±6.49bcd | 10.67±1.42bc | NGJ | 61.29±0.80ab | 10.62±0.36bc |
GZ10 | 54.66±5.29bcd | 10.05±1.72bcde | PWJ | 55.96±4.22bcd | 9.90±1.00bcdef |
Tab. 5 C. roseus fresh biomass and dry weight with inoculated of different AM fungi
菌株编号 Strain number | 鲜重 Fresh biomass/g | 干重 Dry weight/g | 菌株编号 Strain number | 鲜重 Fresh biomass/g | 干重 Dry weight/g |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 51.56±7.70def | 10.28±0.76bcd | LC-C58 | 52.48±5.66cdef | 9.00±1.75def |
JX70 | 63.68±4.90a | 13.08±0.79a | E16-1-32 | 54.03±3.59cde | 9.60±1.28bcdef |
JX80 | 44.25±1.37g | 8.36±0.63ef | E26-47 | 53.70±2.58cdef | 10.26±0.80bcd |
JX126 | 46.63±5.83fg | 8.17±1.51f | BNMJ | 51.92±1.39def | 11.01±0.96b |
JX145 | 56.55±3.25abcd | 10.09±0.69bcde | HTJ2-60 | 54.80±5.94bcd | 10.19±0.67bcd |
JX165 | 47.21±0.92efg | 8.37±0.60ef | LJCK | 55.60±3.86bcd | 10.76±1.01bc |
GZ1 | 50.99±8.32def | 9.15±1.87cdef | LSJ | 59.85±2.46abc | 11.02±0.68b |
GZ5 | 55.39±6.49bcd | 10.67±1.42bc | NGJ | 61.29±0.80ab | 10.62±0.36bc |
GZ10 | 54.66±5.29bcd | 10.05±1.72bcde | PWJ | 55.96±4.22bcd | 9.90±1.00bcdef |
菌株编号 Strain number | 感病率 Susceptibility ratet/% | 病情指数 Disease indext/% | 相对防效 Relative prevention effect/% | 菌株编号 Strain number | 感病率 Susceptibility ratet/% | 病情指数 Disease indext/% | 相对防效 Relative prevention effectt/% |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 57.14 | 37.78 | 0.00bcd | LC-C58 | 50.00 | 24.17 | 37.34abc |
JX70 | 45.45 | 21.11 | 45.27abc | E16-1-32 | 38.46 | 20.67 | 46.42abc |
JX80 | 54.55 | 29.72 | 22.94abcd | E26-47 | 100.00 | 53.89 | -39.72d |
JX126 | 66.67 | 33.33 | 13.58abcd | BNMJ | 28.57 | 12.78 | 66.87a |
JX145 | 75.00 | 45.83 | -18.83cd | HTJ2-60 | 40.00 | 21.67 | 43.82abc |
JX165 | 41.67 | 21.67 | 43.82abc | LJCK | 55.56 | 26.67 | 30.86abc |
GZ1 | 14.29 | 8.33 | 78.39a | LSJ | 33.33 | 16.67 | 56.79ab |
GZ5 | 57.14 | 28.89 | 25.10abcd | NGJ | 50.00 | 26.39 | 31.58abc |
GZ10 | 41.67 | 22.50 | 41.66abc | PWJ | 28.57 | 11.67 | 69.75a |
Tab. 6 Effects of inhibition HLB on C. roseus with different AM fungi species
菌株编号 Strain number | 感病率 Susceptibility ratet/% | 病情指数 Disease indext/% | 相对防效 Relative prevention effect/% | 菌株编号 Strain number | 感病率 Susceptibility ratet/% | 病情指数 Disease indext/% | 相对防效 Relative prevention effectt/% |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | 57.14 | 37.78 | 0.00bcd | LC-C58 | 50.00 | 24.17 | 37.34abc |
JX70 | 45.45 | 21.11 | 45.27abc | E16-1-32 | 38.46 | 20.67 | 46.42abc |
JX80 | 54.55 | 29.72 | 22.94abcd | E26-47 | 100.00 | 53.89 | -39.72d |
JX126 | 66.67 | 33.33 | 13.58abcd | BNMJ | 28.57 | 12.78 | 66.87a |
JX145 | 75.00 | 45.83 | -18.83cd | HTJ2-60 | 40.00 | 21.67 | 43.82abc |
JX165 | 41.67 | 21.67 | 43.82abc | LJCK | 55.56 | 26.67 | 30.86abc |
GZ1 | 14.29 | 8.33 | 78.39a | LSJ | 33.33 | 16.67 | 56.79ab |
GZ5 | 57.14 | 28.89 | 25.10abcd | NGJ | 50.00 | 26.39 | 31.58abc |
GZ10 | 41.67 | 22.50 | 41.66abc | PWJ | 28.57 | 11.67 | 69.75a |
[1] | Bové J M. Invited review Huanglongbing: A destructive, newly emerging, century old disease of citrus[J]. Journal of Plant Pathology, 2006,88(1):7-37. |
[2] | 范国成, 刘波, 吴如健, 等. 中国柑橘黄龙病研究30年[J]. 福建农业学报, 2009,24(2):183-190. |
[3] | 柴梦颖, 周士锋, 冯林剑, 等. 长春花引种栽培关键技术与园林应用[J]. 河南农业, 2017(9):47-48, 50. |
[4] | 柯穗, 李开本, 柯冲, 等. 通过菟丝子成功地将黄龙病病原从柑桔传到长春花[J]. 福建省农科院学报, 1986(1):11-16. |
[5] | 田亚南, 柯穗, 柯冲. 应用多聚酶链式反应(PCR)技术检测和定量分析柑桔黄龙病病原[J]. 植物病理学报, 1996(3):53-60. |
[6] | 吴强盛. 丛枝菌根真菌提高植物抗病机理研究进展[J]. 长江大学学报(自然科学版)农学卷, 2010,7(2):72-75. |
[7] | 黄京华, 曾任森, 骆世明. AM菌根真菌诱导对提高玉米纹枯病抗性的初步研究[J]. 中国生态农业学报, 2006,14(3):167-169. |
[8] |
罗巧玉, 王晓娟, 李媛媛, 等. AM真菌在植物病虫害生物防治中的作用机制[J]. 生态学报, 2013,33(19):5997-6005.
DOI URL |
[9] |
Artursson V, Finlay R D, Jansson J K. Interactions between arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and bacteria and their potential for stimulating plantgrowth[J]. Environmental Microbiology, 2006,8(1):1-10.
DOI URL PMID |
[10] | 刘润进, 陈应龙. 菌根学[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2007. |
[11] | 廖楠, 张金莲, 李冬萍, 等. 甘蔗根系内生真菌染色方法探讨[J]. 西南农业学报, 2016,29(4):814-819. |
[12] | 王幼珊, 张淑彬, 张美庆. 中国丛枝菌根真菌资源与种质资源[M]. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2011. |
[13] | 刘润进, 李晓林. 丛枝菌根及其应用[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2000: 1-2. |
[14] |
Bolan N S. A critical review on the role mycorrhizal fungi in the uptake of phosphorus by plants[J]. Plant Soil, 1991,134(2):189-207.
DOI URL |
[15] | 李晓林, 曹一平. VA菌根吸收矿质养分的机制[J]. 土壤, 1993(5):274-277, 281. |
[16] | 齐国辉, 陈贵林, 吕桂云, 等. 丛枝菌根真菌对重茬草莓产量和品质的影响[J]. 果树学报, 2001(6):341-344. |
[17] | 李海燕, 刘润进, 束怀瑞. 丛枝菌根真菌提高植物抗病性的作用机制[J]. 菌物系统, 2001(3):435-439. |
[18] | 张伟珍. 丛枝菌根真菌对箭筈豌豆炭疽病的影响[D]. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2019. |
[19] |
Basth E, Hayman D S. No effect of VA mycorrhiza on redcore disease of strawberry[J]. Transactions of the British Mycological Society, 1984,82(2):534-536.
DOI URL |
[20] |
Schenk P M, Kazan K, Wilson L, et al. Coordinated plantdefense responses in Arabidopsis revealed by microarray analysis[J]. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2000,97(21):11 655-11 660.
DOI URL |
[1] | YANG Wenwu,GUO Dongqin,CAO Weiguo,PAN Xingjiao,XUE Yanbing,ZHANG Jie,ZHOU Nong. Effects of 27 Strains of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi Inoculation on Physiology and Biochemistry and Major Components of Terpenoids in Potted Saussurea costus [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(9): 1822-1830. |
[2] | SUN Chenyu,ZENG Yanhong,MA Junqing,LIU Lu,WANG Wenqi,HUANG Jinghua. Effects of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi on Artemisia annua L. Growth and Chemical Composition of Root Exudates [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(9): 1831-1837. |
[3] | WANG Feiyan,ZHANG Ruimin,WU Wen,ZHU Congyi,HUANG Yongjing,CHEN Jiezhong,ZENG Jiwu. Effects of Citrus Huanglongbing on Tree Traits and Fruit Quality of Citrus maxima (Burm.) Merr. cv. Shatian Yu [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(9): 1847-1855. |
[4] | ZHANG Jinlian,LIU Jinhua,BAO Han,LI Dongping,SONG Juan,HUANG Jinghua,CHEN Tingsu. A Study to Develop an in Vitro Dual Culture System with Carrot Hairy Roots and Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(8): 1535-1542. |
[5] | HE Chunmei,LIU Cailing,WANG Limin,WANG Fei,ZHANG Hui,CAO Weidong,HUANG Yibin. Comparative Study on Local Cultivars of Astragalus sinicus L. [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(3): 441-448. |
[6] | WANG Yan,XING Dan,SONG Lala,HAN Shiyu,CHEN Tingsu. Effects of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi on Nutrient Exchange in Mulberry Plant in Rocky Desertification Areas [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2020, 41(1): 7-14. |
[7] | DENG Dahao,DENG Tao,ZHOU You,WANG Jun,YANG Laying,GUO Lijia,HUANG Junsheng. Soil Microbial Diversity and Its Response to Soil Physical and Chemical Properties under Different Banana Varieties [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2019, 40(9): 1858-1864. |
[8] | WANG Qian,BAO Han,ZHANG Jinlian,SONG Juan,LIU Zengliang,HUANG Jinghua,CHEN Tingsu. Effects of Different Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi Species on the Growth of Ginger [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2019, 40(7): 1272-1277. |
[9] | WANG Qian, FENG Chongyang, ZHANG Jinlian, SONG Juan, YUAN Zhaonian, HUANG Jinghua, CHEN Tingsu. Seasonal Variation of AM Fungal Community in Rhizosphere of Sugarcane [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(9): 1689-1694. |
[10] | LI Wei, XIAO Xiou, LI Ke, LYU Lingling. Silicon Could Enhance the Resistance to Bacterial Wilt and Increase [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(8): 1540-1547. |
[11] | CHEN Yunlei, LUO Jing, CAI Kailang, CHEN Weiyu, MAI Zhitong, HONG Wenjun. Effects of Inoculation with Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi on the Absorption of Nutrients of Aquilaria sinensis and Dalbergia [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(7): 1290-1296. |
[12] | WANG Xupeng ZHAO Hui JIA Ruizong KONG Hua GUO Yunling GUO Anping. Construction of CRISPR/FnCas9 Plant Expression Vectors with Broad Spectrum Resistance to Hainan Papaya Ringspot Virus by Golden Gate [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(5): 955-962. |
[13] | CHEN Yunlei, LUO Jing, CAI Kailang, CHEN Weiyu, MAI Zhitong, HONG Wenjun. Effects of Inoculation with Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi on the Absorption of Nutrients of Aquilaria sinensis and Dalbergia odorifera [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(12): 2355-2362. |
[14] | GUO Yanfang, WANG Congqiao, LI Rong, CHEN Yukun, LAI Zhongxiong , WANG Tianchi. Cloning and Expression Analysis of PAD4 Gene in Oncidium hybridum [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(12): 2436-2445. |
[15] | QIN Xiaojuan , LIAO Nan , ZHANG Jinlian , LI Dongping LI Song YUAN Zhaonian , CHEN Tingsu. Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungal Diversity and 18S rDNA Gene Sequence Analysis and Identification in Rhizosphere of Sugarcane in Red [J]. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops, 2018, 39(11): 2241-2249. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||